QUOTE(Spot @ Jul 29 2006, 08:58 PM) [snapback]225076[/snapback]
Most of the Jews I know are democrats and liberals. I know that doesn't mean they all support anything that Israel does. But Hezbolla and Hamas both kidnaped and killed Israelis after Israel abandoned their occupied land.
Spot, my view of this mess is that Israel is engaging in collective punishment. I come to that conclusion because, given Israel's reputation for sound intelligence and good strategy, they MUST have known that this type of campaign was unlikely to significantly degrade Hezbollah's capabilities. Given Israel's own statements that Hezbollah hides its weapons and missiles in "schools, mosques, apartment buildings, hospitals", they also must have realized in advance that an air campaign would produce a high number of 'civilian' casualties.
Moreover, they must have known that using this tactic would increase support for Hezbollah, generally inflame anti-Israel sentiment throughout the ME (not to mention, anti-US sentiment), and that the end result would be MORE, not fewer, terrorists and terrorist attacks against Israel.
That's why this is so baffling. There is no benefit to Israel from this, and much harm to its short and long term security.
QUOTE(Brian_Lambchops @ Jul 30 2006, 09:55 AM) [snapback]225262[/snapback]
You bitch about US prisoners, why not ONE WORD about the men Hezbollah took? You don't even know if the men that were taken to START this war are still alive.
Yes, they were still alive as of Friday, at least.
QUOTE(Brian_Lambchops @ Jul 30 2006, 10:03 AM) [snapback]225271[/snapback]
So as long as your buddies in Hezbollah have a nine year old to hide behind, they can't be killed?
Don't you think you've just made the perfect recipe for terrorism that CANNOT BE DEFEATED?
Earth to Lambkins: Yes, it's a perfect technique, because when you shoot both the 9-year-old and the terrorist, the terrorist wins.
Rocco described the means by which this "perfect" technique can be countered, but you just want blood and guts from 15,000 feet instead. (Actually, you personally appear to prefer blood and guts right up close, where you can bathe your elbows in it and bit off a chunk of raw Muslim liver.)
QUOTE(judy @ Jul 30 2006, 10:14 AM) [snapback]225280[/snapback]
They want deaths of children, women and the eldery to get world opinion on their side. And those who are stupid fall for it.
Yes, they do. So why do you keep falling for it and giving them what they want--world opinion on their side? Why do you defend giving the response they hoped for?
Is it just cause you can't think of anything else, or just a general preference for bloodshed over thought?
QUOTE(Repub_Bub @ Jul 30 2006, 10:29 AM) [snapback]225293[/snapback]
The immediate conclusion of this should be obvious...without any support from the West Israel would be at the mercies of either the Arabs or Armageddon.
I don't see how you perceive this to be an option...or, at least a reasonable option for Israel.
I've about had it with Israel. It seems like since 1967 they do everything they can, like this stunt, to make their situation ever more precarious. I'm about at the point of declaring "they made their bed, let them lie in it".
QUOTE(Bart Katz @ Jul 30 2006, 12:37 PM) [snapback]225395[/snapback]
They set their launching points up in or near residences, scools, hospitals, etc. Then when Israel strikes at the targets, Hezbolla gets lots PR against Israel. It's morons like you that buy into that tactic.
No, it's morons like you who keep bombing the targets and giving the terrorists lots of PR and a whole new batch of recruits.
You must be one of the ones who answered my little poll with "Yes, it's wise to use techniques that create more terrorists". Care to explain what's wise about it?