QUOTE(Nomarchy @ Oct 20 2007, 11:54 AM)

Well, as you saw above, my view is that unemancipated minors ought to have the presumption of ZERO privacy vis-a-vis their parents (their actual parents, legally and actually, not their progenitors).
Except under extraordinary circumstancs. I agree with you, actually.
I just think that in an emergency room situation, a doctor should be able to get this information since it is critical to their ability to treat the child. That, IMO, is an extraordinary circumstance. I understand some don't agree, but having "been there" so to speak, and having faced the reality of that situation, I have no problem with it. This isn't something I take lightly, on the contrary, it was a painful realization.
Our courts has ascertained that in order to have the best information to treat the child, doctors need to be able to guarantee the childs privacy in the matters we've discussed.
It is not a perfect system,
but it is the law. I have asserted, that it is what it is, and until someone comes up with something better, it is what we
have. As far as the minors right to reproductive privacy, that decision was made, and remade and remade by our courts, who based those decisions on our laws. Perhaps things have changed to the point that these issues need to be rethought, as I said earlier, I don't disagree.
I am merely pointing out the reality of how things are,
not what I wish could be. I still don't think that people that hold the view that children are the property of their parents have really thought through the issue fully. As I also mentioned before, it was a position I shared, until I was faced with the reality of it.
Believe me, I don't like acknowledging that there is an authority that has an interest in the well-being of MY child more than I do. The fact is, professionals such as teachers and, doctors, and policemen can't read the hearts and minds of the parents involved. They need the tools the courts have granted them to safeguard the most vunerable in our society. Those are "our" children.
As for Fred and Katz attributing attitudes and values that I did not state, nor actually possess, well, that's their usual practice.
I do appreciate the opportunity to debate this with you, Nomarchy. It is an important issue, and one that requires clear thinking, not hysteria.